SILENT HILL: Townfall reviews highlight difficulty: it appears 2.7 times as often as usual
Japanese-language reviews mention difficulty and balance far more often than in typical games. The analysis covers 155 Japanese and 3,380 English reviews posted between September 22 and November 16, 2026.
Own research by 648 News. Every figure in this article was counted by us from 155 Steam reviews written in Japanese and 3,380 written in English, collected between 2026-09-22 and 2026-11-16.
Japanese recommendations fall below the Steam average
155 reviews written in Japanese and 3,380 in English were collected. Steam lists 154 Japanese reviews and 4,228 English reviews. 45.8% of the Japanese-language reviews recommend the game. This share is lower than the 46.1% positive rate on Steam for the whole history of the game, which was read on November 17, 2026. English-language reviews show a 71.5% recommendation rate. Median playtime for the Japanese sample is 16.1 hours. Reviewers with the least playtime, up to 6.9 hours, recommended the game at 44.7%. Reviewers with the most playtime, from 23.2 hours onward, recommended it at 50.0%.
The numbers
Difficulty and story dominate the Japanese sample
The topics that appear far more often than usual in Japanese reviews are story, difficulty, and performance. Story appears in 32.3% of these reviews, which is 3.1 times the typical share. Reviewers discuss the narrative and writing. They mention the Japanese localization and translation quality in 0.6% of reviews. Difficulty and balance come up in 25.2% of reviews, 2.7 times as often as usual. Japanese-language reviewers describe the stealth mechanics as stressful, mentioning enemies that change patrol routes and force long waits. Performance, optimization, bugs, and crashes are mentioned in 31.0% of reviews, 2.1 times the baseline rate. Reviewers point out frame drops and stuttering, particularly during cutscenes and in the Otherworld. They also discuss the PC port quality and Steam Deck compatibility in 1.9% of reviews.
ウェイトの挙動にイライラした。 楽しいところもあるんだけどウェイトが嫌すぎて周回したくない。
I grew frustrated with the Weights behavior. There are fun moments, but I dislike the Weights so much I do not want to replay.
Performance issues divide recommending and non-recommending players
Reviewers who do not recommend the game raise performance problems in 44.0% of their reviews. This is 28.5 percentage points higher than the share of recommending reviews that mention it. The same group brings up story and writing in 28.6% of their negative reviews, which is 3.2 times the baseline rate for complaints. They also mention difficulty and balance in 27.4% of negative reviews, 1.8 times the typical complaint rate. Recommending reviewers talk about characters and character design far more often than those who do not recommend the game. They mention characters in 21.1% of positive reviews, compared to just 3.6% of negative ones. The gap between the two sides stands at 17.5 percentage points.
ステルス系インディーホラー×SILENT HILL的ストーリー…ストーリーとゲームプレイがリンクする”社会派恐怖”の名作
Stealth indie horror × SILENT HILL-style story... A masterpiece of social horror where story and gameplay link.
English reviewers praise the game at a much higher rate
The recommendation rate among players writing reviews in English is 71.5%, which is 25.7 percentage points higher than the Japanese sample. The two groups of reviewers differ significantly in how often they discuss certain topics. English-language reviewers mention story, scenario, and writing in 33.3% of their classified reviews, while Japanese-language reviewers mention it in 32.3%. Gameplay, combat, and core mechanics appear in 64.3% of English reviews and 71.6% of Japanese reviews. Performance, optimization, bugs, and crashes are discussed by 23.7% of English reviewers and 31.0% of Japanese reviewers. Amount of content, length, and replayability appears in 15.3% of English reviews and 22.6% of Japanese reviews. Online play, multiplayer, and servers are discussed in 1.4% of English reviews and 2.6% of Japanese reviews. English-language reviewers mention music, sound, and voice acting in 10.3% of their reviews, whereas Japanese-language reviewers discuss it in only 3.9% of theirs.
Methodology and sources
Data
Steam user reviews, retrieved with Steam's public review listing between 2026-09-22 and 2026-11-16: 155 written in Japanese and 3,380 written in English. Steam's own all-time totals for SILENT HILL: Townfall were read on 2026-11-17.
How the reviews were classified
Every review was read by a language model, which rated how positive it is, how much concrete detail it gives, and which of 15 fixed topics it talks about. The counts and percentages in this article were then computed from those labels in ordinary code, not by the model. Automatic classification makes mistakes, so single percentages should be read as approximate. Reviews of fewer than 15 characters were not sent to the model; they count as positive or negative from the reviewer's own recommendation and carry no topic.
Limits
People who write a Steam review in Japanese are not a representative sample of everyone who plays in Japan, and the language of a review does not establish where its author lives. Steam's default filter for off-topic review activity was left on, so periods Steam marked as review bombing are excluded from the counts in this article. Reviews that arrived after the retrieval date are not included.
Links
Data from Steam. Steam and the Steam logo are trademarks and/or registered trademarks of Valve Corporation.